Shubman Gill’s leadership of the Gujarat Titans (GT) in IPL 2025 has come under intense scrutiny following the team’s elimination in the Eliminator match against the Mumbai Indians (MI). Critics and fans alike have pointed to questionable tacShubman Gilltical decisions and a perceived lack of proactive captaincy as contributing factors to GT’s exit from the tournament.
Captaincy Criticisms
Former India opener Virender Sehwag was particularly vocal about Gill’s captaincy. He criticized Gill for being “not ready” and “not proactive,” especially highlighting the decision to remove Mohammed Siraj from the attack during the powerplay despite his effective bowling. Sehwag noted that bringing in Arshad Khan, who conceded 21 runs in a single over, shifted the game’s momentum in favor of the opposition .
Another decision that drew criticism was the utilization of Prasidh Krishna. In the Eliminator, Jonny Bairstow’s aggressive innings effectively neutralized Krishna, who was considered a key bowler for GT. This raised questions about the strategic planning and adaptability of the team’s bowling approach .
Fan Reactions
The fanbase expressed frustration over the team’s performance, particularly targeting the bowling strategies and field placements. Many fans felt that the captaincy lacked clarity and that the team failed to execute a coherent game plan during crucial moments .
Gill’s Response
In the aftermath of the loss, Gill acknowledged the team’s shortcomings, admitting that critical moments were mishandled. He pointed out that conceding too many runs towards the end and not capitalizing on crucial middle overs were significant factors in the defeat