Nikki’s father, Bhikari Singh Payla, has been devastated by the incident. Calling the accused “butchers,” he has demanded the death penalty for them and warned that if justice is delayed, he will go on a hunger strike. He also urged the authorities to demolish the accused’s house under the state’s law-and-order measures. His words capture the helplessness and rage of a parent who lost his daughter to a social evil that is, in fact, illegal in India.
Despite this, the response from the accused has been chillingly cold. Vipin Bhati, caught after an attempted escape in which he was shot in the leg, showed no remorse. Instead, he dismissed the allegations, claiming that Nikki had died “on her own” and describing the matter as an ordinary marital dispute. His statements not only deny accountability but also reveal how normalized dowry demands and domestic abuse can still be in many parts of society.
The National Commission for Women (NCW) has taken suo motu cognizance of the case and demanded an immediate action report from the Uttar Pradesh police chief. Several arrests have already been made, including Nikki’s husband, brother-in-law, and in-laws, but the demand for strict punishment continues to grow. Civil society voices, activists, and women’s rights groups are urging for fast-track trials to ensure justice is not delayed.
This case is a stark reminder that dowry is not only a regressive cultural practice but also a crime under Indian law. The Dowry Prohibition Act of 1961 makes giving or taking dowry illegal, while sections of the Indian Penal Code and the newer Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita provide stringent punishments for dowry harassment and deaths. Sections like IPC 304B (dowry death), IPC 498A (cruelty by husband or relatives), and Section 113B of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, which presumes guilt when dowry harassment is established, exist to protect women. Yet, as Nikki’s death shows, the implementation and enforcement of these laws remain patchy.
The story of Nikki Bhati is not just about one woman—it reflects the persistence of a deep-rooted social evil that continues to claim lives despite being outlawed. Her father’s chilling demand for justice reflects the urgency with which society and the legal system must respond. Until dowry practices are eradicated and laws are enforced with consistency, the lives of countless women remain at risk.